Are You a Scientist?
The notion that science and religion are at war
is one of the great dogmas of the present age. For journalists, it is a prism
through which to understand everything from the perennial kerfuffles over
teaching evolution to the ethics of destroying human embryos for research. To
many scientists, religious belief seems little more than a congeries of
long-discredited pre-modern superstitions. For many religious believers, modern
science threatens a deeply held faith that man is more than a mere organism and
that our status as free beings bound by natural law implies the existence of a
transcendent deity.
But this is not the whole story. Every year, countless new books try to
reconcile the claims of truths revealed by divine inspiration and those that
are the product of earthly reason. Foundational developments and arcane
speculations from theoretical physics — from the latest findings of quantum
mechanics to the search for a “Theory of Everything” — take on a metaphysical
import in the popular mind. One of the best known examples involves the
cosmologist Stephen Hawking, who famously concluded his 1988 bestseller A
Brief History of Time with the suggestion that our search for
scientific meaning may someday allow us to “know the mind of God.” More
recently, Hawking has backed away from this statement. His new book, The
Grand Design, which posits that the universe may have created
itself out of quantum fluctuations, is but the latest in a long line of volumes
by prominent physicists and cosmologists translating scientific theory for a
popular audience. Along with volumes by biologists with a flair for explaining
complex concepts, these books have become a locus of debate about the place of
God and man in our understanding of the universe.
This taxonomy is worth keeping in mind while considering two recent books,
each of which takes up the subject from the perspective of scientists. The
first is a nuanced portrait of the religious beliefs of scientists working in
the United States today; the second is a collection of writings from scientific
luminaries, both historical and contemporary, laying out their thoughts on
religion. Taken together, these books proffer an answer to the following
question: Just what do scientists — including the most influential scientists —
actually believe concerning religion?
To be continue...
No comments:
Post a Comment